Harry Potter vs. Twilight

SweetEchoJenn · Post by **SweetEchoJenn** » 11 Oct 2020, 20:25

Altho I enjoyed both, Harry Potter is definitely more compelling and more indepth. Just better!

DianaMich · Post by **DianaMich** » 05 Jan 2021, 15:09

I have read both and enjoyed them. I think Harry Potter has much better dialogs, plot, descriptions, and much more. I could read the HP books over and over. As for twilight I read them just once and enjoyed them, but I don't think ill ever read them again.

Ink-Drinker-13 · Post by **Ink-Drinker-13** » 14 Jan 2021, 20:39

Harry Potter 100%. I don't feel that the two are even comparable honestly. But that's my personal opinion.

cbear5 · Post by **cbear5** » 17 Jan 2021, 11:00

Harry Potter all the way! I mean, it’s a classic and not much can beat it.

Liveforchrist51 · Post by **Liveforchrist51** » 29 Mar 2021, 19:44

These both are amazing! I would have to choose Harry Potter though. They are much more detailed and the movies match up better with the books also.

Linda S 1 · Post by **Linda S 1** » 23 Aug 2021, 03:55

Harry Potter for sure. It's one of my favorite books ever.

Amna Khalid · Post by **Amna Khalid** » 01 Oct 2021, 09:10

Definitely Harry Potter books and movies.

Scott Fling · Post by **Scott Fling** » 19 Dec 2022, 03:21

I believe that Stephen King said it best: "Harry Potter is all about confronting fears, finding inner strength, and doing what is right in the face of adversity. Twilight is about how important it is to have a boyfriend."

Carlos Mata Saenz · Post by **Carlos Mata Saenz** » 06 Apr 2023, 14:45

I love the results of this! I think Harry Potter is so complex that it just works beautifully. I respect so much Twilight as well, but not many series are over HP in my opinion.

Paul Link · Post by **Paul Link** » 19 May 2023, 12:33

Harry Potter. Twilight can't hold a candle to Harry Potter. Twilight was too prose heavy and the plot wasn't very suspenseful. Harry Potter has complex themes, action, suspense, and much more lovable and realistic characters.

Alissa Nesson · Post by **Alissa Nesson** » 29 Jan 2024, 15:21

Harry Potter is amazing. I don’t think Twilight even comes close.

Varisha Khanna · Post by **Varisha Khanna** » 19 Jul 2024, 10:21

Definitely Harry Potter!
There are way better vampire shows and movies out there in my opinion. I can’t wrap my head around sparkling vampires at all .

London Baum · Post by **London Baum** » 21 Jan 2025, 22:25

These are hard to compare because they’re such different types of books, but I think Harry Potter is better overall.

The entire wizard world and Hogwarts is so detailed and descriptive and that takes a lot of good writing to uphold. I love twilight but making vampires who live in our modern world just isn’t the same. I also think the rest of twilight series books are just slightly worse than the last where Harry Potters are all (in my opinion ) equally as good as the first.

AsterAlder · Post by **AsterAlder** » 28 May 2025, 11:22

Harry Potter is a clear winner for me even though I did enjoy Twilight. I feel like Harry Potter had more world building and there were just more characters and dynamics to fall in love with. It helps that there were more books and I grew up while they were all coming out. Twilight was fun and I enjoyed reading the books with friends but the stories felt more - focused? Both were wonderful in their own way though and I would recommend both series.