OnlineBookClub.org

Hey!

So, I've never actually read "The Hunger Games" books but I've watched the films. In my opinion, the films are a absolutely spectacular and I loved every single one of them. When it was announced that Mocking Jay part 2 was the last one, I honestly cried.
But my question is - Are the Hunger Games books better, worse or the same as the films? Should I read them?

Thanks!

Hey, I think that the books are so much better, but the movies are actually really great too. My favorite is the first because I like the beginning of stories the most. I feel like they portrayed the book the best in the first movie.

The Hunger Games trilogy is amongst my favorite books of all time so I'm heavily biased towards them. I think Catching Fire was the best film, but Mockingjay, which was my favorite book, was just butchered. You know that scene at the end of Part II where Katniss yells at Buttercup? Whenever I read that part it always made me cry. In the film it was emotionless. That just expresses what was wrong with the last two films. So I would say yes, you should definitely read the books.

The books have so much more depth to them. However, the last one is a little political for me. This doesn't detract from the fact that the books are certainly better than the movies. You should totally read them.

I think the first and second books are much better than the first and second movies. However, I was not a big fan of the third book, especially the ending. I liked the way the third movie wrapped up a lot better. It felt as though there was more closure there.

Mely918 wrote: ↑01 Jun 2018, 23:32 However, I was not a big fan of the third book, especially the ending.

Yeah, I have heard a lot of people say that. I guess that just comes down to one's tastes. Personally, I was dreading that the book would have the cliche "good guys kill the bad guys and live happily ever after" ending, so I really liked how the story ended.

Thanks for your replies guys! Looks like I am going to start reading the books!

AliceofX wrote: ↑02 Jun 2018, 03:12

Mely918 wrote: ↑01 Jun 2018, 23:32 However, I was not a big fan of the third book, especially the ending.

Yeah, I have heard a lot of people say that. I guess that just comes down to one's tastes. Personally, I was dreading that the book would have the cliche "good guys kill the bad guys and live happily ever after" ending, so I really liked how the story ended.

That's understandable. I would have disliked the book/movie even less if it had that cliche. Yeah, it does come down to one's personal opinions on whether they like or dislike the story's ending.

You should definitely read them. Catching Fire (the film) was the absolute best film remake of a book, but the Mockingjay book is much better than the movies. These novels are fascinating, and the movies did a great job. Nothing compares to emotionally connecting to characters by reading about them, so pick up the books!

My friends got me to watch the movies, and as you said it was spectacular. I then read all the books. Without a doubt, the books were better than the movie. The way the author explains the characters actions, feelings and thoughts, made me cry more than any other book I've ever read. This, however, did not take away any of the brilliance of the book. On the contrary, it enhanced my love for the movie franchise. I could now watch the movies and see the little details that kick the movie up a notch. So to conclude, yes read the books, you won't doubt it.

-brintontaylor wrote: ↑02 Jun 2018, 15:01 Thanks for your replies guys! Looks like I am going to start reading the books!

Good call! I read them all in a couple of days when I was on holiday. Then I watched the first movie. The movies are well done, in my opinion, but the books give so much more detail. You probably have read them by now. I hope you liked them!

Books are almost always better in my opinion! They usually come first and therefore offer a lot more details. Same for The Hunger Games.

Hey! I read the first book the hunger game and I couldn't put it down the movie was ok the book has more details in it then the movie did the movie was good the main actresses played katniss perfect! I wish I could have read the other books! The book was great to read!

I couldn’t agree more , the books are better because of the detail they include but the movies do bring it to life !

I think the first film handled the ending much better. In the book the dead tributes come back as werewolves. I thought that was dumb. The movie had the attacking ... dogs? ... or whatever they were, created by the Capitol and unrelated to the dead tribunes. I thought that was a cleaner way to do it. Bringing back Rue as a monster just doesn't do it for me.