Page 1 of 2

If this were a movie, who would play Charlie?

Posted: 21 Oct 2016, 10:49
by Joy Boudreau
Who would play Charlie? Looking for someone who could be timid, but yet bold, could look sort of "normal." What else should describe who would play Charlie (or any of the other characters)?

Charlie - Natalie Dormer or Meghann Fahy
Sheila - Jennifer Aniston
Doug -
Scott -
Asa -
Amos -
Martha -

Re: If this were a movie, who would play Charlie?

Posted: 21 Oct 2016, 21:20
by Janetleighgreen
greenstripedgiraffe wrote:Who would play Charlie? Looking for someone who could be timid, but yet bold, could look sort of "normal." What else should describe who would play Charlie (or any of the other characters)?

Charlie - Natalie Dormer or Meghann Fahy
Sheila - Jennifer Aniston
Doug -
Scott -
Asa -
Amos -
Martha -
Oh! This question is fun!!!???

Re: If this were a movie, who would play Charlie?

Posted: 23 Oct 2016, 08:06
by BrandyBeaudin
If this was a movie I would have to say I would love Jennifer Gardner to play Charlie and her love intrest would be Matt Damon!!! Lol

Re: If this were a movie, who would play Charlie?

Posted: 23 Oct 2016, 09:11
by MrsCatInTheHat
Renee Zellweger would be great in the role of Charlie.

Re: If this were a movie, who would play Charlie?

Posted: 24 Oct 2016, 01:16
by Gnome
I would say that I can see Natalie Dormer better as Martha. Of all the roles I've seen her in, she's done the best when she's plotting and planning rather than reacting. Due to the nature of this haunting Charlie spends more time reacting to the ghosts while Martha initiates the action.

For Amos, I think I would like to see someone who has never done a horror movie. I'm imagining someone who is typecast as an action hero or comedian taking a step back and acting a bit awkward.

Re: If this were a movie, who would play Charlie?

Posted: 24 Oct 2016, 04:53
by Heidi M Simone
Great question! I am terrible with actors'/actresses' names, but for Asa, maybe Johnny Depp? He has that crazed-look (and sometimes creepy) about him, but can be attractive as well. And even though there are evil parts to Asa, there is still that conflict of him being not so bad and not really wanting to continue to hurt people. I think having someone who is known to be a bit out there, but well-liked will help the conflict people feel towards Asa.

Re: If this were a movie, who would play Charlie?

Posted: 24 Oct 2016, 07:23
by Janetleighgreen
hsimone wrote:Great question! I am terrible with actors'/actresses' names, but for Asa, maybe Johnny Depp? He has that crazed-look (and sometimes creepy) about him, but can be attractive as well. And even though there are evil parts to Asa, there is still that conflict of him being not so bad and not really wanting to continue to hurt people. I think having someone who is known to be a bit out there, but well-liked will help the conflict people feel towards Asa.
Oooh! Johnny Depp, yes!!! I can see him as Asa for sure!

Re: If this were a movie, who would play Charlie?

Posted: 24 Oct 2016, 10:26
by Joy Boudreau
hsimone wrote:Great question! I am terrible with actors'/actresses' names, but for Asa, maybe Johnny Depp? He has that crazed-look (and sometimes creepy) about him, but can be attractive as well. And even though there are evil parts to Asa, there is still that conflict of him being not so bad and not really wanting to continue to hurt people. I think having someone who is known to be a bit out there, but well-liked will help the conflict people feel towards Asa.


definitely johnny depp- hadn't thought of him, but that's a good call!

Re: If this were a movie, who would play Charlie?

Posted: 24 Oct 2016, 22:10
by Megwe85
I think Anna Kendrick could play Charlie.

Re: If this were a movie, who would play Charlie?

Posted: 25 Oct 2016, 23:15
by gali
I think Jack Nicholson would be perfect as Asa. Maybe Kathy Bates as Martha?

Re: If this were a movie, who would play Charlie?

Posted: 26 Oct 2016, 06:38
by Heidi M Simone
Janetleighgreen wrote:
hsimone wrote:Great question! I am terrible with actors'/actresses' names, but for Asa, maybe Johnny Depp? He has that crazed-look (and sometimes creepy) about him, but can be attractive as well. And even though there are evil parts to Asa, there is still that conflict of him being not so bad and not really wanting to continue to hurt people. I think having someone who is known to be a bit out there, but well-liked will help the conflict people feel towards Asa.
Oooh! Johnny Depp, yes!!! I can see him as Asa for sure!
greenstripedgiraffe wrote:
hsimone wrote:Great question! I am terrible with actors'/actresses' names, but for Asa, maybe Johnny Depp? He has that crazed-look (and sometimes creepy) about him, but can be attractive as well. And even though there are evil parts to Asa, there is still that conflict of him being not so bad and not really wanting to continue to hurt people. I think having someone who is known to be a bit out there, but well-liked will help the conflict people feel towards Asa.
definitely johnny depp- hadn't thought of him, but that's a good call!
Thank you! Glad it wasn't too far-fetched! :D

Re: If this were a movie, who would play Charlie?

Posted: 26 Oct 2016, 08:40
by Janetleighgreen
gali wrote:I think Jack Nicholson would be perfect as Asa. Maybe Kathy Bates as Martha?
Those two would be great for Asa & Martha had they lived to be older, they were in their 30s when they died. ?

Re: If this were a movie, who would play Charlie?

Posted: 26 Oct 2016, 08:42
by gali
Janetleighgreen wrote:
gali wrote:I think Jack Nicholson would be perfect as Asa. Maybe Kathy Bates as Martha?
Those two would be great for Asa & Martha had they lived to be older, but remember, they died pretty young. They were in their early 30s, late 20s...
Indeed, but otherwise... 8)

Re: If this were a movie, who would play Charlie?

Posted: 26 Oct 2016, 08:57
by Janetleighgreen
gali wrote:
Janetleighgreen wrote:
gali wrote:I think Jack Nicholson would be perfect as Asa. Maybe Kathy Bates as Martha?
Those two would be great for Asa & Martha had they lived to be older, but remember, they died pretty young. They were in their early 30s, late 20s...
Indeed, but otherwise... 8)
Agreed. I had to amend this response because I thought about Amos' being so much younger than Martha. They would've had to have been in their 30s. Ha!

Re: If this were a movie, who would play Charlie?

Posted: 26 Oct 2016, 12:26
by Joy Boudreau
would you have the same actor play both Charlie AND Martha?