Visionary or Imagination?

[ebethina]

That is a hard question. I remember when I read in the book Sara had drawn a bear that no one had seen in years. Therefore, no one else believed her when she said she saw the bear and draw. Plus, since the bear hung around long enough for her to draw it. Then there is the tale she was in. Who knows? The tale she was in could have been both visionary and imaginative.

[Monroe1987]

Both. We see her imagination in her art and in the way she tells the stories. As a visionary, we see her display her skills.

[Job Njoroge]

One can argue she was either although I am left wondering whether you can have a vision without imagining it?

[Nishant Das]

Imagination facilitates vision. I think she had a great imagination first and then decided to turn that into vision when she started practicing throwing in real life too.

[Joy Boudreau]

This was not just an imagination working. There was either a vision or a reality or a mix, but not imagination, as imagination implies it is coming from within. A vision is an external influence.

[BoyLazy]

Both. We see her imagination in her art and in the way she tells the stories. As a visionary, we see her display her skills.

Beautifully explained. Loved her visionary part.

[Amagine]

This was not just an imagination working. There was either a vision or a reality or a mix, but not imagination, as imagination implies it is coming from within. A vision is an external influence.

I love your answer even though I still believe it could've been both.

[jonaya]

I think she was a visionary person as a word go says 'without vision people perish' no wonder she was able to overcome or accept anything that comes on her way.

[kwahu]

I think she envisioned all that she was telling. Yeah as a way to prepare her for life in the park. The stories she had heard may have triggered that.

[Jennifer Allsbrook]

Do you think that Sarah was a visionary, or do you think she just had a real good imagination?

I think she had to have been a visionary, in order to have learned the skills that she needed, such as throwing.

I do believe Sarah was a visionary in this story. She would have to be in order to learn the skills. Also, the descriptions that she provided were much to specific to be just figments of her imagination. Knowing the habits and behaviors of ancient people with which she was not previously familiar would be a little difficult to just think up.

[Chigozie Anuli Mbadugha]

I think she may have experienced some of it and imagined the rest...

[K_Robinson]

I always described it as a visionary sequence, so I guess I assumed it was a vision rather than her just making something up. That combined with her being strongly adamant that it felt so real and she had learned so much from it that could be applied to "real" life makes me feel as if the author wanted it to be a vision.

[powergirl]

Sarah seemed to be visionary and imaginary she found stories and completed them even hardly.

[ritah]

She needed to be susceptible to fiction for that vision to be so realistic to her.

true.

[Marylynn]

I think she was visionary since magic was involved and not imaginative.