OnlineBookClub.org

This is a discussion topic for the November 2023 Book of the Month, Artwords by Beatriz M. Robles.

What do you think of the use of calligrams and photographs in poetry as opposed to other traditional styles?

The use of calligrams and photographs in poetry represents a departure from traditional styles, introducing visual elements to complement or enhance the written expression. Calligrams, with their visual arrangement of text, and photographs can add layers of meaning, fostering a more immersive experience for the reader.

These unconventional approaches can be powerful tools for conveying emotions, perspectives, and atmospheres. They engage the reader in a multisensory experience, breaking away from the constraints of purely verbal communication. However, the effectiveness depends on the poet's intent and the synergy between words and visuals.

Ultimately, the choice between traditional and visual styles in poetry is subjective and depends on the desired impact. Each approach offers unique opportunities for artistic expression and connection with the audience.

I think it adds another artistic layer and complexity. I am not really for or against using them, but if the author chooses to use them it should be done in a way that enriches the written word as opposed to just adding it for the sake of adding it or making the book more confusing to read.

I think that the use of calligrams and photographs was a leap from the traditional style which makes the poem not only interesting t read but also easier to comprehend.

It is a milestone from the traditional poetry.. Alot has been made realistic and charming in today's calligrams

I liked how creative the calligrams were. I did find them at bit confusing at first, however, it was a nice new experience for me.

I think photographs along with poetry is a good idea. It will help the readers to understand the mind and feelings of the poet. What the poet was going through, etc.

Although traditional poetry forms offer their unique charm, introducing calligrams and photographs into poetry presents a dynamic and inventive method of poetic expression. This approach enriches the genre by merging visual arts with literary craftsmanship, thereby elevating the reader's experience for many. The term "many" is used here to acknowledge that a segment of the audience still holds a preference for classical interpretations and reading of poetry. Ultimately, the merit lies in one's ability to derive enjoyment and appreciation from their reading, without there being a definitive correct or incorrect way to engage with poetry.

Marie Chalupová wrote: ↑19 Dec 2023, 15:04 I think it adds another artistic layer and complexity. I am not really for or against using them, but if the author chooses to use them it should be done in a way that enriches the written word as opposed to just adding it for the sake of adding it or making the book more confusing to read.

I totally agree. When well executed, these types of poems can be very visually stimulating and add a whole new layer of meaning. At times, these poems can become too distracting with the visuals, or cause the poems to be difficult to read and therefore less enjoyable.