Official Review: purgatorio by bernard kuckuck

[Quentin Russel]

Although this is a well written review I don't think this book will be of interest to me. I like historical fiction, but the book sounds like it doesn't have the kind of driving plot that would appeal to me. I've never really found the history of music to be of much appeal.

I can understand your perspective! Historical fiction can be fascinating, but it really depends on the themes that resonate with each reader. However, it does explore broader themes like philosophy which could still be engaging. What kind of historical fiction do you usually enjoy?

[Quentin Russel]

The first scene in the sample where a ballroom is filled with musicians and performers set in the 16th century made me realise this might not be a book for me. Readers who love a historical storyline and are interested in music will like this one. Thanks for the review. Congrats on the BOTD!

The historical and musical setting might not appeal to everyone, especially if those elements aren't your preferred. However, I think the way the book blends real historical figures with fiction makes it an interesting read for those who enjoy rich, immersive storytelling.

[Quentin Russel]

I love music and would appreciate learning new musical terminology in Italian. Also the romance of platonic love is intriguing. I may belong to the.linited audience who will appreciate this book.

I also love the Italian language, and I think the musical terminology and historical details in this book make it even more enriching.

[Quentin Russel]

Very nice review. I read the sample pages also but this book did not grab my attention as I am not into classical music nor the time period in which this story was set.

It definitely is a limited audience. If history, poetry, and/or opera doesn't catch your attention, this isn't the book for you.

You make a great point! However, I do think the way it explores art, philosophy, and platonic love could still appeal to some readers outside its core audience.

[Quentin Russel]

Historical fiction is a type of genre that doesn't give a lot of freedom as compared to the others because of its primarily condensed reach and already existing historical concepts. But such a book, I believe is a perfect example of beautiful historical fiction is and purgatorio from this review sounds like an amazing book to read.

I see your point! Historical fiction does have its limitations since it needs to stay true to historical events and figures, but I think that’s also what makes it fascinating.

[Quentin Russel]

The review is in-depth, making it easy to decide whether to read the book or not. I like to explore the author's work, especially with a focus on music, art, and history. The fact that there are few inconsistencies with the names of those in the book wouldn't deter me from reading it; thanks for the heads up, though. I will watch out for it. You did a great job with this review. Kudos and congratulations to the author on being selected for BOTD.

The name inconsistencies might be a minor issue, but they don’t take away from the richness of the narrative.

[Bethel Saint Bright]

There's a deep music culture in Italy. I'm glad this book captures this deep culture in it's narrative. My interest is piqued.

[mrlefty0706]

"Purgatorio" by Bernard Kuckuck is a historical novel that takes place in late 16th century Florence, Italy as the country prepares for the wedding of Maria Medici to King Henry IV of France. A group of well-known musicians and composers decide to create an original melodic entertainment for the wedding. Maestro Lorenzo had told the group after a lively rehearsal at the Palazzo Medici of an unsent letter by Beatrice Portinari to Dante Alighieri. The mention of this letter prompted Filippo, a talented music student under Maestro Lorenzo to create his own drama musical based on the poet Dante and his Lady Beatrice. Filippo is very lucky to be part of this incredible group of composers and his musical could be his first step toward success and fame of his own. He was encouraged by Maestro Lorenzo’s niece Beatrice who was friends with Filippo, but was already engaged to a very talented swordsman named Eugenio Igneo. While the primary focus of the story was music, the issues of the time period including religion, politics and philosophy had a huge influence on the musical compositions. Very prominent men were mentioned in the story including Pope Boniface VIII, Machiavelli and Lorenzo de Medici. The book was educational and readers will learn that Dante watched Beatrice enter the church from across the street for nine years, which makes me wonder why Beatrice never sent the letter she wrote to Dante. I would like to read the entire book for the romantic and historical aspects of this story. The official reviewer only gave the book 3 out of 4-stars because of the many confusing spelling of names and the fact that the book may only appeal to a limited type of reader that loves history and musicals from the 16th century. I think there are many types of people that will enjoy reading this story.

[Bhimlendra Kumar 1]

Great review! You have written a very balanced and informative piece. Those interested in history and music will enjoy this book even more, and I agree with your point. Congratulations on being declared 'BOTD'!

[Miracle Obazie]

Thank you so much for the review. The historical information about the book is well researched on focusing on different themes making it informative and entertaining

[Abiodunakinola]

This book masterfully blends historical fiction with musical artistry, immersing readers in the rich cultural landscape of 16th-century Florence. The inclusion of real historical figures like Giulio Caccini and Ottavio Rinuccini adds authenticity, making the novel a fascinating exploration of the early development of opera. Nice review.

[Tars]

Interesting story, but a bit confusing, like often happens with historical fiction that uses names of real historical places and people. How much of the events in the book are real? Medici family and King Henry indeed existed, so won't I be considered a dummy if I mention some event described in the story, only to find out it never happened?! I believe it's better to pass, but still congrats on BOTD!

[Amy_Jackson]

Sounds like an intense book. I love music and my interest is piqued by the historical names mentioned. I'm also interested in knowing more about the platonic love,, which seems to be a thing not easily found. These all make up a good book for me.

[Armin1]

The story is set up in 16th-century Italy and revolves mainly around music. Music and history enthusiasts will enjoy reading this book. Fillipo's passion for music sounds great. I wonder how music is translated to a reading novel. It will be interesting to find out.

[twinkle09]

Thanks for a great review. Though i enjoy historical books, i am not musically inclined and musical jargons and phrases are going to make me feel lost. I am going to pass on the book.