Official Review: Misreading Judas by Robert Wahler

Juliet Ezihe · Post by **Juliet Ezihe** » 06 Jun 2025, 08:44

EvaDar wrote: ↑03 Aug 2018, 17:01
Dael Reader wrote: ↑03 Aug 2018, 15:17 An interesting review. I am not completely familiar with the gnostic mystic theology, but I am one of those who believe that Judas's role in gospel stories has, perhaps, been misinterpreted. The guy gets a bad rap that he doesn't really deserve! I don't know if I'll jump tor had this one just yet, since I'm looking for some lighter fare. But this is a compelling review.
Yes, I recommend something else for lighter reading. But if you are interested in the story of Judas, I think you would enjoy this, when you are in the mood for religious academia. Thanks so much for taking the time to read the review and comment.

Tim Terry · Post by **Tim Terry** » 06 Jun 2025, 08:56

An in depth review of a book about a very controversial subject. I've always been fascinated by the history of the Bible and I know about the various interpretations of Judas. I could add a lot of extra facts here, but I suppose I should actually read the book itself before I do that. Nevertheless, your review sparked a keen interest in me to do that and I enjoyed it immensely.

Joshua Joseph 9 · Post by **Joshua Joseph 9** » 06 Jun 2025, 09:08

I mean the book makes you see life from a different point of view and perspective I've always wonder why and the author just clarified it to me too

Post by **Rupali Mishra** » 06 Jun 2025, 09:30

Congrats on BOTD.
"Misreading Judas" turns years of biblical convention on its head. Imagine if Judas replaced Jesus as intellectual leader instead of betraying him. A thorough examination of Eastern spirituality, Gnosticism, and the Gospel of Judas that challenges your preconceived notions.

Amos Osinya · Post by **Amos Osinya** » 06 Jun 2025, 09:50

"Misreading Judas" invites one to an interesting revelation. One that is against our traditionally held belief about Jesus and Judas. Am interested in exploring this book to find out how the author lines up his defence to his opinion and thoughts. I will recommend it to a friend too to find it and read it. Congratulations book of the day

Zakahle Ciliza · Post by **Zakahle Ciliza** » 06 Jun 2025, 10:23

The book gives insights to Judas's point of view of of his part, his internal struggles with carrying such a heavy burden betraying Jesus was one of his most regretful choices that lead Jesus to his imposing death.

I would say that such a heavy burden has carried him for a long while.

Post by **Kibet Hillary** » 06 Jun 2025, 10:35

I have read the review, but I cannot already tell that this departs, indeed, very widely from orthodox Christianity. In fact, the Gospel of Judas would even go against some of the prophecies in the Old Testament books, including Psalms. The book sounds interesting, though. Many thanks for the review, @EvaDar.

Erva troka · Post by **Erva troka** » 06 Jun 2025, 10:53

You managed to unpack Wahler’s complex thesis in a way that feels both respectful and intellectually stimulating. I appreciate how you acknowledged the controversial nature of the book while still giving space to its merits—especially the comparative analysis and the unique mystical lens Wahler applies. Your summary helped me better understand the significance of his reinterpretation of Judas, and now I’m genuinely curious to read Misreading Judas myself. Whether or not I agree with all of Wahler’s conclusions, I can see how this book could spark some deep reflection and important conversations. Great job!

Chi Chiu Michael Mak · Post by **Chi Chiu Michael Mak** » 06 Jun 2025, 11:02

Bible/Christian/Catholic/Gnostic readers interested in the story of Judas's "betrayal" would be mind blown at the notion of Misreading Judas. I am interested to see why this book has a different take and what events in the records caused this rift.

Post by **Judy Burr** » 06 Jun 2025, 11:11

Thank you for your review. I sampled a few pages. A book about Judas Iscariot is a deep study of his relationship with Jesus, a story of betrayal in the Bible. The author offers a curious mystical relationship that is handed down by masters. I will pass on this book.

Dolores Lee · Post by **Dolores Lee** » 06 Jun 2025, 11:22

I really appreciate your thorough review of this book. I like reading non fiction books, but I'm not interested in books focused on religion. I always end up having more questions at then end than when I started.

Post by **Seetha E** » 06 Jun 2025, 11:27

This looks like a controversial topic. Nothing better than a healthy debate that allows all parties to express their views. This book is sure to interest many.
Thank you for your comprehensive review.

Post by **Sanju Lali** » 06 Jun 2025, 12:02

A nice attempt to provide a proof about the popular belief about Jesus of Nazareth was incorrect by offering a new interpretation of the relationship between Jesus and Judas in the book "Misreading Judas" by Robert Wahler.

Post by **Anu Anand** » 06 Jun 2025, 12:09

Judas as a self-sacrificing disciple rather than a betrayer really shifts the whole story. The idea of mastership succession rooted in mysticism was new to me and quite fascinating. I’m curious to know more about this complex topic. Congrats on BOTD!

James Hanna · Post by **Wamboi Susan** » 06 Jun 2025, 12:32

"What if someone provided proof that our long -held beliefs about Jesus of Nazareth were incorrect? Author Robert Wahler is attempting to do just that with his 2016 non-fiction book, Misreading Judas: How Biblical Scholars Missed the Biggest Story of All Time. " This seems to me like a radical shift in my understanding of Judas and Jesus and i agree with the reviewer's comment on reading it with an open mind.