How to request another "editor" read/score review?

[Jennifer Allsbrook]

How can a member of the review team request that another editor read and score a review that is already published? Several of my reviews have at least two editor comments but my most recent review only has one. Can a reviewer request additional feedback? Is so, how does it get done? Thanks in advance!

[bookowlie]

There were likely two editors who made comments and scored the review. From what I remember, the policy is that not all editors' comments are shown; instead, they are displayed randomly. As a result, you wouldn't need to request another set of eyes; instead, you could ask to see the other editor's comments that are already in the system. If the motivation for the request is to have an additional edit/score due to being dissatisfied with your existing score/comments, that sounds more like a grievance. In any event, Scott would be the one to contact.

[gali]

There were likely two editors who made comments and scored the review. From what I remember, the policy is that not all editors' comments are shown; instead, they are displayed randomly. As a result, you wouldn't need to request another set of eyes; instead, you could ask to see the other editor's comments that are already in the system. If the motivation for the request is to have an additional edit/score due to being dissatisfied with your existing score/comments, that sounds more like a grievance. In any event, Scott would be the one to contact.

-- January 20th, 2017, 6:24 am --

How can a member of the review team request that another editor read and score a review that is already published? Several of my reviews have at least two editor comments but my most recent review only has one. Can a reviewer request additional feedback? Is so, how does it get done? Thanks in advance!

It should be done privately and not on the open forums. If you have any issue with your score/reviews, please privately contact Scott, the webmaster, about it.

[Jennifer Allsbrook]

How can a member of the review team request that another editor read and score a review that is already published? Several of my reviews have at least two editor comments but my most recent review only has one. Can a reviewer request additional feedback? Is so, how does it get done? Thanks in advance!

Thanks for the information. I didn't realize that not all editor comments were shown. Constructive criticism is how we improve.